Ultra-rare mutations highlight the importance of the HD gene in brain development
New technology enables researchers to find ultra-rare mutations in the HD gene, distinct from the one causing HD
A relatively new technology called exome sequencing has identified a few families with novel mutations in their HD genes. These are different than the mutation that causes HD, but allow researchers to better understand the normal role of the HD gene.
Normal HD gene function
The mutation that causes HD instructs brain cells to make an abnormal, mutant protein scientists call huntingtin. We’ve long known about the many ways mutant huntingtin protein can interfere with cells’ normal processes. For example, mutant huntingtin can interfere with brain cells’ ability to move cargo from one end of the cell to the other and impair cells’ abilities to produce energy.
What we’re less sure about is: what exactly is healthy huntingtin supposed to be doing in the cell in the first place, and what happens when it’s not around to do its job? (You can read more about the “Hunt for the Function of Huntingtin” here: http://en.hdbuzz.net/221.) Two recent discoveries highlight how healthy huntingtin may play critical roles in the development of our brains and nervous systems, giving us new information to keep in mind as we develop treatments for HD.
Before we go into the findings, here’s a quick crash course on the technique that made it all possible: whole exome sequencing. Our DNA is comprised of over 3 billion letters. But surprisingly, the cell only reads about 1.5% of that genetic blueprint to make proteins. The 1.5% of our DNA that codes for proteins are called exons.
Sequencing technologies, which allow scientists to read the information coded in DNA, have advanced very rapidly over the past decade or so. It’s now possible for researchers to read all 3 billion letters to get a person’s complete genetic code. Researchers call this whole genome sequencing. But, sequencing all 3-billion letters to look for a tiny mutation is like looking for a needle in a haystack. To make the haystack smaller, researchers instead can sequence only a subset of the genome - often just the subset of a person’s DNA that codes for proteins, the exons.
This process of sequencing only the protein-coding regions is called whole exome sequencing, and results in a haystack about 1.5% as big as a whole genome. Two different research groups using whole exome sequencing incidentally made important new insights about the normal function of the HD gene.
Rare HD gene mutations discovered
“We aren’t certain what impact the new, non-HD genetic mutations are having on the huntingtin protein. But, based on the genetic region where the mutations occur and what we know about the protein’s structure, it is likely that the mutations are dramatically reducing the amount of huntingtin protein in the cell ”
The first group of researchers was searching for genetic mutations in a group of nineteen people with severe developmental disorders. Their symptoms, including intellectual disability, limited speech and motor abilities, and repetitive motions such as hand wringing, were characteristic of a disease called Rett syndrome. But, like HD, Rett syndrome is caused by a mutation in a specific gene—and these people did not have the mutation known to cause Rett syndrome.
To try and solve this mystery, researchers used whole exome sequencing to search for the mutations in every gene that might explain these symptoms. They identified several new mutations in these individuals, but one person in particular is relevant to our story here at HDBuzz: a woman with mutations in both copies of her HD genes. The woman didn’t have HD because her HD gene mutations were different than the type that causes HD. And, while most carriers of HD only have the mutation in one huntingtin gene, both copies of this woman’s huntingtin genes carried these novel mutations.
At the same time this study was happening, another group of researchers were searching for the cause of a developmental disorder in an Ecuadorian family. The family was comprised of two healthy parents, one healthy child, and three children with severe developmental delays. The affected children’s symptoms included little or no language skills, dramatically impaired motor abilities, and repetitive motions like hand wringing. None had a mutation in the gene that causes Rett syndrome.
To try to discover the underlying mutation, these researchers performed whole exome sequencing on the Ecuadorian family. They discovered that the developmentally delayed children had mutations in both copies of their HD genes. Again, they were new mutations—not the specific mutation that causes HD.
In both of these studies, researchers also performed whole exome sequencing on the healthy parents of the people with developmental disorders. In both sets of parents the mother and father each carried one mutated HD gene. However, their other copy of huntingtin was healthy. In the Ecuadorian family, the sibling that didn’t have developmental delays also carried one copy of mutated HD gene and one healthy copy. The only people that experienced developmental disorders were those that inherited two mutated HD genes.
We aren’t certain what impact the new, non-HD genetic mutations are having on the huntingtin protein. But, based on the genetic region where the mutations occur and what we know about the protein’s structure, it is likely that the mutations are dramatically reducing the amount of huntingtin protein in the cell. This type of mutation (called loss of function) is different than the type of mutation that causes HD. In HD, the mutation leads to production of a toxic, abnormal huntingtin protein—but it does not affect the amount of huntingtin protein that’s being made.
So - just to be clear - these mutations are not the same as the mutations which case HD. But by random chance they happened to occur in the HD gene, and so help us better understand what the HD gene does, beyond being mutated in people who develop Huntington’s Disease.
What do we learn?
These studies have taught us several important things about huntingtin. First, they show that just a single copy of “healthy” huntingtin is sufficient for the brain to develop and function normally. We know this because parents and siblings that had one “healthy” huntingtin gene were fine, even though their other copy was mutated.
This finding also supports what we’ve observed in two other people with rare huntingtin mutations that caused one copy of the gene to be inactivated, or turned off. People with one inactivating mutation were healthy as long as their other copy of huntingtin was ok. We have also seen the same type of outcomes when we study huntingtin in mice. Mice missing one copy of the huntingtin gene are healthy, as long as their other copy of huntingtin is still intact. Together, these findings suggest just one copy of functional huntingtin is enough to carry out most of its essential functions.
“These discoveries have taught us that there is a critical role for huntingtin in brain development. Each of the people with loss-of-function mutations in both copies of their huntingtin genes were diagnosed with severe developmental disorders. ”
Next, these discoveries have taught us that there is a critical role for huntingtin in brain development. Each of the people with loss-of-function mutations in both copies of their huntingtin genes were diagnosed with severe developmental disorders. Whole exome sequencing did not reveal any other mutations that were likely to be the culprit. Hence, these rare, unfortunate cases have given us a glimpse into the normal function of huntingtin and what happens to the brain when there’s insufficient huntingtin to support normal brain development.
Gene silencing for HD - still OK?
Understanding the normal functions of huntingtin has long been a focus of the HD research community. Knowing what huntingtin is doing in the cell may lead to new insights about HD or spark ideas to develop treatments. Importantly, the normal function of huntingtin is relevant to an investigational HD treatment called gene silencing. (You can read more about gene silencing in this post: http://en.hdbuzz.net/204.)
Gene silencing turns down the levels of the HD gene to prevent the production of mutant, toxic huntingtin protein. Given what now know about the critical role of huntingtin in brain development, it will be important to carefully monitor HD patients receiving gene-silencing treatment. It also means we will have to strategically evaluate the age of HD carriers undergoing huntingtin gene silencing - attempting to silence the HD gene in the brains of very young people would raise serious safety concerns.
But, since the vast majority of HD patients are adults whose brains are already fully developed, it’s unlikely that gene silencing will lead to the problems seen in these patients who had low huntingtin levels throughout development. Researchers and physicians will be sure to keep all of this in mind during clinical trials with gene silencing drugs.
And of course, none of these insights would have been possible if it wasn’t for whole exome sequencing. This powerful technique allowed researchers to identify for ultra rare mutations that advance our understanding of many diseases—including HD. This new research shines a light onto huntingtin’s critical role in brain development, adds to our knowledge about HD, and helps us plan gene silencing studies which are safer for participants.